Bridging the "Client Expecation Gap" in Personal Training

In personal training, few dynamics are more misunderstood—or more corrosive—than what I call the Client Expectation Gap. This gap in perception can have long-term effects on trust, satisfaction, retention, and even team culture in a training department. However necessary it is for the industry, it's an important concept to understand so you aren't falling victim to it.

Let’s dig into why this matters, and what we can do about it.

What Is the Client Expectation Gap?

Simply put, the Client Expectation Gap is the difference between the price a client pays for a training session and the compensation the coach receives to deliver that session. This is much more than just a transactional issue.

Here’s the breakdown:

• A client books a session for $120/hour.

• The coach conducting the session earns $60/hour (at best) from that session.

(Consulting note: Gyms at best will provide a 50%/50% split for training sessions. This means the trainer is being paid 50% of the $ value of the service)

That’s a 50% split, which many trainers would consider a favorable cut. In plenty of commercial gyms, that number is far worse. It’s not uncommon to see trainers earning $30–$40 per session on a $100–$120 sale price.

So what’s the problem?

The problem is the math isn't mathing. It’s in the mismatch of expectations.

From the client’s perspective, they’re paying premium prices for a premium service. They expect expertise, preparation, attention, customization, and results.

They’re paying $120 for one hour of someone’s time. Many clients believe that money is going directly to the professional they’re working with.

From the trainer’s perspective, they're only receiving $60 for that session and in most situations are only giving as much as a $60 effort (sometimes less) The trainer might feel overworked and undervalued—particularly if they’re pushing through multiple sessions daily just to break even.

And between those two mindsets, lies the Client Expectation Gap.

The Emotional Toll of the Gap on Personal Training

This gap doesn’t just affect take-home pay—it impacts relationships.

When a trainer knows a client is paying $120/hour, but they’re walking away with $45, the motivation to go above and beyond can fall apart at times.

They might still show up on time and provide a decent workout, but the level of investment starts to decline.

The client—who is spending at a luxury service rate—expects a polished, professional, and fully engaged expert.

If they sense their trainer is distracted, worn out, or mailing it in, frustration starts to build.

“Why am I paying so much for this?” is the natural thought.

That frustration might never be voiced, but it often leads to decreased session frequency, skipped renewals, or ghosting altogether saying there is an issue with finances or they are "moving".

It’s Not About the Gym Being the Villain

Let's be fair, the gym HAS to maintain a split of 50% to make the service make sense for them. Gyms hold all the liability, curate the environment, upkeep the equipment, and maintain a space where you can thrive as a professional. This isn't an indictment on gyms by any means.

As a gym consultant, I actively encourage gyms to maintain at minimum a 50%/50% split.

But that doesn’t change the emotional math for the client or the coach. And when no one talks about it—when the entire system is built on this—resentment starts to build.

Examples That Hit Home

Let’s take two scenarios:

Scenario A: High-End Gym

• Session Price: $120/hour

• Trainer Pay: $60/hour

• Gap: $60 per session

Let’s say a client does 3 sessions a week for 12 weeks—36 sessions.

• Client spends: $4,320

• Trainer earns: $2,160

Scenario B: Mid-Tier Gym

• Session Price: $80/hour

• Trainer Pay: $35/hour

• Gap: $45 per session

Same 3 sessions a week for 12 weeks:

• Client spends: $2,880

• Trainer earns: $1,260

At this point, the gap is wider than the coach’s earnings. The client is still paying a significant amount—but the coach is walking away with less than half.

If the trainer starts canceling or seems less enthusiastic, the client might assume they don’t care. In reality, the trainer is likely just burning out while chasing their goal income to make this a career.

So How Do We Close the Gap?

We may never fully eliminate the Client Expectation Gap, but we can close it.

That starts with acknowledging it exists—and building better systems around transparency, structure, and delivery.

Here are several ways to take steps in the right direction:

1. Build a Professional Experience Regardless of the Payout

Even if a coach is making $35/session, the session should be delivered as if it’s worth $120. Because to the client, it is. Treating it that way is what builds long-term trust, referrals, and renewals. In the long game, that can lead to more sessions, higher status, and eventually better pay.

2. Improve Client Education (Tactfully)

Clients don’t need to know your paycheck—but they should understand the value of what they’re getting.

• Talk about the pre-session planning you do.

• Explain the programming model you’re using.

• Show how your check-ins and notes guide their program.

• When you say you will provide them homework, DO IT

• 
  

This helps the client see they’re paying for more than just the hour. They’re paying for the result, not the hour.

3. Use the Gap as Motivation—Not Resentment

Lastly, use the knowledge of this gap as a motivator to build your career. It should push you to:

• Level up your skill set

• Create multiple revenue streams (online coaching, workshops, group training)

• Develop a brand that commands higher value

The most successful trainers aren’t the ones who complain about the system—they’re the ones who outgrow it. Eventually, it is expected that coaches outgrow the environment they began in.

Final Thoughts: We All Deserve More Clarity

The Client Expectation Gap is a silent source of stress, burnout, and misalignment in the training world. Clients deserve to know they’re getting value.

Coaches deserve to be paid in a way that reflects the energy and professionalism they bring to the table.

Gym owners deserve models that don’t force them to choose between business margins and staff well-being.

In short, no one wins when expectations aren’t aligned.

The goal is better relationships, better results, and a better industry.